A Supply Side Solution to Michigan's Ailing Economy

Friday, March 5, 2010

So I recently wrote a paper for a scholarship on how to fix Michigan's economy. I thought it'd preface my blog post about the Arthur Laffer presentation, so I'm posting it here. Enjoy :)

"The current economic outlook for Michigan is rather bleak, with unemployment peaking at a staggering 15.8% of the total workforce, more than double of unemployment figures in January 2008 (BLS).  In 2009 alone, 300,000 jobs were lost in the state of Michigan. In this same time period of January 2008 to present, the civilian labor force has decreased 3.39%, signaling an increase in the number of discouraged workers in Michigan. Meanwhile, Michigan’s government is facing record deficits, with $1.6 billion of projected deficits for FY10 alone. It is clear that we need to make reforms to fix Michigan’s economy. 

The proposed solution to Michigan’s economic woes is perhaps not as revolutionary as one might expect. The policy solution outlined is, in majority, embodied by the school of economic thought known as supply side economics. Championed by famous economists of the 1970s (e.g. Arthur Laffer) and brought into practice by President Reagan (coining the term “Reaganomics”), supply side economics operates upon the fact that firms who hire workers for production cause a proportional increase in income in the economy. This is called Say’s Law. As these workers who receive income are also consumers, production side incentives create certain effects on demand. In other words, supply side factors “trickle down” into demand. 

Unfortunately, Michigan’s business tax code is somewhat less than ideal. The Michigan Business Tax (MBT) is composed of a Business Income Tax of 4.95%, a Modified Gross Receipts Tax of 0.8%, and an extra Surcharge Tax of 21.99%. 

According to a study by the Anderson Economic Group, the effective business tax rate as a percentage of profits for the year 2008 ranked 22nd in the nation. Similarly, Michigan’s “State Business Tax Climate Index (SBTCI)” assigned by the tax foundation was 5.35, ranking Michigan 17th in the nation. To the average reader, these numbers may not seem so bad, as 22nd and 17th in the nation are both well above the national median. However, a more in depth analysis of these numbers can be very enlightening. 

Contained within Michigan’s  SBTCI is its Corporate Tax Rating, which ranks an uncompetitive 48th. No matter what one’s economic philosophy, the fact is that corporate taxes are one of the largest factors in many business decisions. A review of the economic literature involved will prove this. In a 1982 study, Newman showed that tax differentials among states were a major factor for the movement of industry to southern states. Harden and Hoyt concluded in 2003 that corporate taxes have the largest negative effect on the rate of growth in employment. Also, according to a 2001 study by Agostini and Tulayasatheien, for “foreign investors, the corporate tax rate is the most relevant tax in their investment decision.” 

In other words, high corporate taxes significantly hinder economic growth. Paired with supply side ideals, the two point to a powerful economic tool. The solution is simply to lower corporate tax rates. However, at a time of record deficits, a tax cut must be accompanied by a spending cut. As part of the current Michigan Business Tax, a wealth of tax credits is offered to businesses. Michigan’s government can start by cutting these tax credits, as they only serve to decrease the negative impact of a poorly-written tax code. 

The aggregate of these reforms should lead to a tax code that includes: a uniform corporate tax rate of 6.0%, continuation of Michigan’s Modified GRT Tax (a Value-Added Tax (VAT) in econ-speak, a highly efficient tax), and the elimination of most of Michigan’s tax credits that only serve to unlevel the business playing field. 

As stated previously, the solution presented is far from revolutionary. However, they are elegantly so. A few simple policy changes can lead to a number of changes that improve Michigan’s economy.
The most obvious effect of a corporate tax cut is that businesses have more profit as a percentage of revenue. Noting this as an important business incentive and keeping in mind that states are in a constant state of competition with surrounding states, businesses will unquestionably decide to relocate from an area with high tax rates to an area with low tax rates. The influx of business will significantly increase the amount of skilled labor in the workforce and will help to lay the foundation for the economy in the long term. 

Also a result of this effective increase in business income, firms will begin to hire more workers. However, as the economy does not exist in isolation, wages paid to workers by definition leads to a mirror increase in total income of the economy. Given this extra income, consumers will undoubtedly spend a portion of it, which increases demand for products in the economy. This increase in demand will lead firms to supply more of their goods, hiring workers in the process. Rinse and repeat. 

As evidenced above, decreasing corporate tax rates leads to more economic activity. This is nothing short of a blessing from a deficit reduction standpoint. The additional economic transactions provide a larger tax base for existing taxes. While it is slightly preposterous to claim that a decrease in taxes will lead to an increase in tax revenue, a corporate tax cut will in part be funded by the increase in economic activity involved. 

As you see, the suggested solutions will solve a host of Michigan’s economic problems and, with the necessary deficit reduction measures, come at little cost to Michigan’s government. All of these proposals are sound economic fact; the only obstacle lies in political attainment."

Economics, Philosophy... Cows?

Thursday, March 4, 2010

Sorry the post about my meeting with Dr. Arthur Laffer is so late... It's taking me a bit longer than I expected to write it. I did meet him, and the post will be up soon. Further details will have to wait until the actual post.

In the mean time, I read a very interesting post on Marginal Revolution yesterday (link here: Philosophical Cow). Here's an excerpt:

"Suppose that you are a cow philosopher contemplating the welfare of cows.  In the world today there are about 1.3 billion of your compatriots.  It would be a fine thing for cows if all cows were well treated and if none were slaughtered for food.  Nevertheless, being a clever cow, you understand that it's the demand for beef that brings cows to life.  How do you regard such a trade off?

If each cow brought to life adds even some small bit of cow utility to the grand total of cow welfare must not beef eaters be lauded, at least if they are hungry enough?  Or is the pro beef-eater argument simply repugnant?"
The scene is reminiscent of the "push-man-onto-train-tracks-to-save-three-innocent-children" scenario. More precisely, it is the little theoretical concept usually used in Philosophy classes to disprove rational thought. If you have the choice to push a man onto the train tracks to save three innocent children, killing the man in the process, any economist will tell you to push the man off (three lives for one is clearly beneficial for society). However, many people probably couldn't bring themselves to do so given the choice.

I suppose this is why behavioral economics has arisen, taking into account the fact that people don't always think rationally.

Perhaps you couldn't picture yourself as the cow, but faced with one of these situations, what would you do?

So Evidently I'm Meeting Arthur Laffer Tomorrow

Monday, March 1, 2010

To say that I'm excited would be an understatement. I'll keep you updated :)

LOLFed... Wow. Just Wow.

Friday, February 26, 2010

So I was reading Jodi Beggs' blog when I came across a post about LOLFed. If you don't get what this is, either stop failing at life or go look up what LOLCats is all about :P

Anyways, check the site out. I'll be adding it to the quick links bar on the left there. I'll also post a few of my favorite ones :)

LOLFed  (Note: Uber-Nerds only)




Destined for Econ?

Wednesday, February 24, 2010

In a recent interview with Greg Mankiw (full interview here: Mankiw Interview), Mankiw describes his reasons for becoming an economist. I found it interesting that his description is almost a completely accurate description of my academic interests. I won't lie; it was kind of creepy. Here's the excerpt:

"WellesleyWeston Magazine: You have had a remarkable career both in the public and private sector. What is it about economics that piqued your interest? 

Greg Mankiw: I first became interested in economics during my freshman year at Princeton. One of my friends was taking a microeconomics class; I started reading her textbook and found that I like economics, a lot. In many ways I am a prototypical economist. Economists share a couple of characteristics: they tend to be naturally better in math and science—economics is fairly quantitative—and they are generally more interested in public policy and social issues than in the substance of science. I have always been interested in politics—dinner conversation in my home often centered on what was happening locally and in Washington. But politics by itself seemed vague, random, and subjective. Economics appealed to me because it brought an analytic perspective to social policy questions."

A System Without Incentives Pt. 2

Tuesday, February 23, 2010

In my post a few days ago, I detailed one of the reasons for senioritis, chiefly that the GPA scale is based on a 4.0 scale, and that there is no difference between a 90% and a 99%. As if to add insult to injury, most of my teachers...

2. Give assignments that are not graded, but checked for completion (credit-based).

Before I go into a criticism of the checked-for-completion homework system, I'd like to give an example of a teacher who has it right. My junior year pre-calculus teacher knew how to work the system. He would give us our homework just as any other teacher does, but he would check eight random problems that we did. Not only that, he would grade our homework out of five (aka a lot of extra credit).

If we examine this system a bit, it becomes clear what is missing from the traditional credit-based system. Not only does it encourage sloppy work, it doesn't even encourage one to do his own work. Assume that I am a rationally thinking student thinking to maximize the value of my resources (time). Because the work is credit based, I will choose to do a poor job while spending little time rather than doing superb work that takes much time. The simple reason for this is that there is no difference between quality work and garbage work in a credit-based homework system. Why waste the extra resources when they contribute to nothing? By the same token, why even do your own work? Because copying homework poses a very small risk of getting caught in a credit-based system (as, by definition, the teacher is not closely checking the work;otherwise it would be graded), a rational individual who truly wishes to maximize his returns on his limited resources will choose to copy someone else' homework.

I understand the teacher's rationale for using a credit-based homework system: it's simply too convenient. With little to no work, the teacher can get his students to do work with minimal checking. However, they may not realize the perverse incentives system it creates. For maximum effect, may I suggest trying my pre-calculus teacher's method? I am in no way suggesting that it is perfect; grading eight problems and putting it out of five created large amounts of extra credit that brought out the worst of the GPA issue I discussed in my earlier post. However, such a system is indeed much more efficient at achieving the ultimate goal: to get students to quality homework.

I, of course, am no where near rational or amoral enough to cheat, but I have found myself spending less and less time doing worse and worse work. I believe this post explains the reasons for this.

If I began with an example of an exemplary teacher, I'd like to end with a not-so-exemplary one. The following teacher taught me a certain social studies related class, and I will never forget the work (or rather the lack of it) that I did in that class. All of the homework that we did was tracked by pages and lines. For example, we would have to take a page of notes, write a three line answer, or answer the question in a paragraph. You get the point. The result? Every student in the class had a wide ruled notebook, wrote in gigantic handwriting, and finished sentences on the beginning of a line.

Incentives matter. Q.E.D.  

A System Without Incentives

Saturday, February 20, 2010

Even senioritis can be explained by economics. I was sitting at home the other day, trying to focus on my calculus homework, when I realized that I simply had no motivation to continue. Unable to concentrate, my mind drifted and began thinking about the cause of my lack of motivation. Below are my conclusions. I will present my thoughts over the course of my next few blog posts. 

1. The GPA system at our school does not incentivize me to go beyond what's minimally required.

For the unaware, our school awards a 4.0 for an A in any class (90%-100%). Let's assume, for a minute, that the grade you get in a class is directly proportional to the time you invest into it and that you can predict perfectly the time you need to spend to get a certain grade (aka perfect information). In this case, why would any student invest more than the minimally required time to get a 4.0? They wouldn't.

However, seeing as perfect information is not available in real life (though I would argue that our first assumption holds true in general), people invest extra time to get higher grades purely as a measure of insurance. For example, not knowing how hard the final will be, you study more than what is necessary to get a 90%. As such, we can analyze the market for grades using insurance analysis (substituting price for time and grade for output). Saving the mathematical analysis for a later date, I'll simply note that the most important thing to keep in mind is that most people are risk adverse and tend to prefer at least some degree of insurance. This is more or less due to the fact that marginally, a very small increase in the number of hours invested can yield a very large increase in GPA (for example, the GPA difference between an 89% and a 90% is an entire point, but it may only take a few extra minutes of studying to achieve that 1% increase).

But even with this in mind, it's important to note that there is virtually no difference between a 98% and a 90%. I realize now that the later on into the year I go, the less my high school grades actually matter. As a result, I've become more risk tolerant because the potential downfall from a negative outcome (getting a low grade) has become significantly less.

School systems realize this perverse incentives system and many have taken the necessary steps to remedy it. Many schools now operate based on a 100 point scale, directly scaled to a student's percentage score. This system, in my opinion, is much better for motivating a student to achieve to his fullest, as the amount of time you invest will now be correctly reflected in your GPA.

Now That's Service!

Monday, February 15, 2010

We've been having some serious internet issues as of late, with our internet switching on and off repeatedly for the last 3-4 days. I, being the computer junkie that I am, thought that I could fix it myself. As it turns out, I couldn't (not really my fault though, turned out the issue was with a virus on our laptop that was jamming our wireless signal).

Exasperated, I finally gave our ISP a call (undoubtedly with a hint of annoyance in my voice). Throughout the course of my conversation with the ISP representative, I happened to mention that I was so upset that I would be switching ISPs. Lo and behold, three hours later, there was a technician at my door, chirp and eager to fix the problem.

Though the technician wasn't able to fix the issue (we had to call my dad's IT friend), the little episode is demonstrative of a principal of private enterprises: they seek profits. The lady on the phone was so concerned about losing a customer that she made an exception and sent a technician to our house on the same day I made my complaint.

As for me, I'll be switching to another ISP. I wouldn't want to reward failure.

Hopefully AT&T will have better internet technicians.

Graphical Analysis of the Fed Balance Sheet

Friday, February 12, 2010

I was reading Ben Bernanke's speech a couple of days ago (you can read it here: Fed's Exit Strategy) and I really began to wonder what the Federal Reserve's balance sheet looked like. Well, here it is... kind of.

The breakdown of the assets are posted below in two graphics. It doesn't show the Fed's liabilities, but those are straight-forward enough (i.e. money deposited to banks).

I would have just posted the table, but that's not as fun as looking at these and trying to figure them out :)





NOTE: Click to enlarge

Sex Ratios on College Campuses

Wednesday, February 10, 2010

A couple of very interesting reads from Marginal Revolution:

Supply and Demand
Revisiting the Marriage Market

The following passage I found especially interesting. It proposes a overly-simplified, albeit very concise and powerful model about how the "marriage market." Pair this with the unequal sex ratios of college campuses, and you can have some interesting results. I'll have to keep this in mind in selecting a college...

"Imagine... a marriage supermarket.  In this supermarket any man and woman who pair up get $100 to split between them.  Suppose 20 men and 20 women show up at the supermarket, it's pretty clear that all the men and women will pair up and split the $100 gain about equally, $50,$50.  Now imagine that the sex ratio changes to 19 men and 20 women.  Surprisingly, a tiny change in the ratio has a big effect on the outcome.
Imagine that 19 men and women have paired up splitting the gains $50:$50 but leaving one woman with neither a spouse nor any gain.  Being rational this unmatched woman is unlikely to accede to being left with nothing and will instead muscle in on an existing pairing offering the man say a $60:$40 split.  The man being rational will accept but this still leaves one women unpaired and she will now counter-offer $70:$30.  And so it goes.
If you follow through on the logic it becomes clear that in the final equilibrium no married (paired) woman can be significantly better off than the unmarried woman (otherwise the unmarried woman would have an incentive to muscle in with a better deal) and so because the unmarried woman gets nothing the married women can't get much more nothing.  Thus when the sex ratio is 20:20 the split is $50:$50 and when the sex ratio is 19:20 the split is more like to $99:$1 in favor of the men.
 The key simplification of the marriage supermarket is that the next best option to marriage (pairing) is worth $0--thus there is a long way to fall from the equal sex ratio equilibrium of $50.  If the outside option is worth more then changes in the sex ratio will have smaller effects.  Nevertheless, the logic of the marriage supermarket explains why a relatively small change in the sex ratio can lead to a large change in sexual and other mores affecting the marriage equilibrium."